crossthatbridge

Friday, June 27, 2008

Susanne Speaks in the Pioneer Valley

My friends at GoNomad have the good fortune to live and work right up the street from one of the nation's premier liberal arts colleges; Amherst, Massachusetts. And even though I stopped in only briefly, I could feel the free-thinking spirit and smell the sweet pizza slices wafting in from Antonios. You know your in a college town when that happens.

You also know your in a college town when a woman like Susanne Hoder can give a powerful, revealing, 2 hour presentation on her visit to the Holy Land without retribution.

She visited the region for several months staying with Christian, Islam and Jewish families alike; sharing Rosh Hashanah with a Rabbi, Communion with preachers and Ramadan with Muslims. When she returned home she decided to gather her thoughts, photos and film on the subject and share it with America.

Susan provides a rare insight on Middle East tensions, the sensitivities of all three religions and the culprits of why the conflict continues.

"We can't protect Israeli's if we only understand Israeli's," she says. "We also have to understand what's happening to Palestinians if we want to protect Israelis."

Susanne points out that many measures the Israelis take to make Israel safe are actually doing just the opposite. She also points out that the general Israeli public (as well as us Americans) are unaware of the extent of aggression and intimidation used in the West Bank and Gaza Strip to segregate the three cultures. She's right.

Be it the residuals of WWII or the close bonds of a representative democracy or my misunderstanding of the Muslim religion, I've always felt more sympathy with the Jewish plight than the Muslim plight." But this isn't about religion insists Susan.

"This is a struggle about land," she says. It's not an animosity between 2 peoples because of the religion they practice or antisemitism. It's a process of a people loosing their land and water and opposing that process."

Susan goes on to point out flagrant violations of the Geneva Convention including destroying biblical land for shopping malls, settlements and industrial parks for use by one ethnic group alone. Intimidation, hostility, torture and the building of a giant wall called the "Matrix of Control" also cuts the region into pocketed isolated areas.

Of course, this infuriates and instigates the Christian and Muslim Palestinians and if you've ever watch television news it's the car and bus bombings that you'll see, not the forced occupation of privately owned land that's causing it.

There's so much more to this topic but for a travel blog I think I've gone well beyond the parameters of my usual light and fluffy topics. Still, for those interested in learning more visit here and here. Thanks for reading.

1 Comments:

At 2:05 PM, Blogger Unknown said...

Israel/Palestine is one complex topic for sure.

It sounds as if Susan Hoder has made a real effort to get to know the country and not see just one side of the conflict.

Something I've always found very strange is that if you criticize the state of Israel you are accused of being 'anti-Semitic' - in this case being critical of Judaism, although Arabs are also 'Semites'.

Criticism of Israel does not have to mean criticism of Jews' right to exist but of Israel's actions alienating its neighbors and the original inhabitants of Palestine being either outright killed or at the least pushed off their land and deprived of the right to farm, deprived of water, work, dignity, all in the name of a Jewish homeland because of the Holocaust.

The Holocaust, the systematic murder of millions, however, took place in Europe - in Germany and Poland and other locations - not in Palestine, not perpetrated by Palestinians but by Europeans.

Why should the Palestinians, who were did not cause the Holocaust, be forced to give up their land because of it?
As retribution for the Holocaust, the Jewish 'homeland' could have been in Bavaria or Prussia or Baden-Württemberg.

The Palestinians who defended their land have been made scapegoats for the real criminals, all of this aggressiveness, torture, alienation of their neighbors, land grabs, and wanton destruction by the Israelis chiefly supported by American tax dollars.

I disagree with Susan that this conflict is not about religion, however. While the tangible problems for the Palestinians caused by the Israelis concern land, water, the right-to-work and more, the discrimination by the Israelis against them is first and foremost based on religion.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home